FINALLY, THE END OF ANOTHER SEMESTER
Oh, how time flies…It has been another wonderful episode with Dr.Edwin. How is that not matter how scared we are of him, that I still feel at ease and a sense of belonging in his class. In SEM 3, it was short stories. Now it is Drama; another interesting genre in literature. No matter how hard it is at times to comprehend Poetry, Short Stories, Novels and Drama, it is the most fun and enjoyable times of life as a TESLIAN. I have high respect for the lectures (Dr.Malachi Edwin Vethamani and Pn.Juridah Md.Rashid) that major in this field. It is not an easy task. It needs concentration, pure hard work and sacrifice. Anyway, this is my first blog ever. Although I have been the member of Friendster (a community page) since 2004, I was never interested in opening my own blog as I thought it is just a waste of time. However, this course has changed my mind about it and I am enjoying myself with this Blog. Even though it is academic based, I still felt honoured to be able to express myself about the things I have learned. A Blog or Forum (in SEM 3) also allows you to develop critical and creative thinking and how to respect other people’s view. It is also helps you to understand the subject matter better as different people see things differently and you might not even thought about those things. Basically, play is one of the wonderful text to read. Honestly I did have difficulty consolidating ‘King Lear’, a Shakespearean play. It took me a long time to finish reading it because of the classic language and frankly speaking it was one of my hardest time. But all these was a new experience which I will treasure always. I hope that I will have the time other Shakesperean play and all the famous plays too boost my knowledge. Thank you Dr.Edwin for this experience!
STREET CAR NAMED DESIRE-THE MOVIE…
Hmmm.. ‘Street Car Named Desire’ a catchy name that will never be understood unless you read the play. First and for most, Congratulations to Marlon Brando who played Stanley and the woman who played Blanchè. Both of them did a wonderful job. Their act was so convincing that I almost believe that is their original characteristics. “Kudos” to the director too who did not even miss a single line from the written text and followed all the setting 100%. Nowadays you can hardly find novel or play adaptations follows exactly from the text. ‘Street Car Named Desire’; at first when I heard the title, I thought it is a bout a street named desire. I know it sounds foolish but I did think in that way. However, as I said before, after reading the text and listening to Dr.Edwin’s explanation that I understood the meaning. Well, there were a few differences in reading the text and watching the movie. Firstly, I understood Blanchè better after watching the movie. During my first reading I did not really understand Blanchè’s desire to be wanted by men but after watching the movie that I saw how Blanchè would do anything to get men and to survive. She’s also kept herself vulnerable and at times naïve even though she can actually predict Stanley’s devilish intentions. I did feel like giving a knock on the head for being so foolish by giving her body out for men and alcohol and finally being taken advantage by Stanley. On the other hand, Stanley played by the charming and handsome Marlon Brando acted marvelously! He deserves an award! His characteristics matched Stanley’s traits. And because of Marlon Brando’s wonderful act that I felt hatred for Stanley, the jerk. Why does man like that exist? Same goes to Mitch and all the other man in the movie. They are man than cannot be relied on. Only looking for own selfish pleasure. In general I did enjoy the movie and it has helped a lot in comprehending the play.
ANIKE AND ANTIGONE
What are the parallelism of this 2 play? Both consist of the sisters Antigone and Ismene and Anike and Yasmin, both the brothers Polyneices and Eteocles and Sirat and Wira, Creon and Maniaka, Tiresias and Tok Seth, Nadim and Haemon. One extra character in this play is the evil Bendahara as Maniaka’s advisor. I loved the way Phui Name wrote this play as it contains the eastern value or culture such as Keris and the Gamelan music. Anyway, one single thing that bothered me is how Sirat was stripped naked, carved and left to be hanged. It is disgusting and inhuman! Even Creon is not as bad as that. At least Polyneices was left lying on the ground. I am amazed of Anike’s determination. How she manage to bring her smelly, soft skinned brother down to the earth and bury him according their traditions. She has so much respect for her brother. On the other hand, Yasmin was quite aggressive compared Ismene. At least Yasmin showed enthusiasm when Anike told her intentions rather than the cold Ismene’s reaction to Antigone. Personelly, I preferred ‘Antigone’ compare ‘Anike’ as it is more classic and acceptable. And I would appreciate it more if Creon cried to death!
“SPEAK WHAT WE FEEL, NOT WHAT WE OUGHT TO SAY”
I had a mass difficulty comprehending ‘King Lear’ by the great William Shakespeare. The language was mind blowing. Anyway, the issue that bothered me the most is the Blindness of Lear and Gloucester. They were both blinded by the false love shown by their children that later lead them to their own disaster. Lear was blinded by Goneril’s beautiful words and Regan endless confessions. I was so enraged by how a father and a king can be fooled easily. This clearly shows that as a father, Lear fail to know his daughters heart to heart. He cannot differentiate sincere words and false words. However, although Cordelia were Lear’s favourite daughter, she failed to answer brilliantly. It is clearly understood she loved Lear the most but her silence and refusal to express her love was an unwise move. She also failed to understand her father. If she knows that her father is a man that can be pleased by words, she can say something to profess her love sincerely from the heart and that would have pleased Lear and she would not end up like that. On the other hand, even Gloucester failed to understand both his sons; Edgar and Edmund. Gloucester fell for Edmund’s trick even though he rarely spends time with him and know him well. Edgar’s years off devotion to his father were not taken into consideration by Gloucester when he decided to agree with Edmund. I’m not trying to be one sided. Although both sons deserved to be loved equally, nevertheless the fact that Edgar is his legitimate son and Edmund is not, Gloucester should have at least thought for one second to ask Edgar personally was it true. Edgar naive ness made the situation worse. The advantage of Edmund not being brought up as a legitimate son has made him an independent and smarter individual that is always finding a way to revenge on his father. Although he is a villain in the play, I like how he developed as a character and I admire his determination. In General, the play was an interesting text to read and I would love it if Shakespeare extended it and wrote about how Edgar, Albany and Kent ruled the government.
WHO IS TIRESIAS?
There are various versions of Tiresias. The first one is Tiresias is a priestess who mates snakes who got married and gave birth. Tiresias is also a prostitute. The other version is Tiresias in Sophocles’s play ‘Oedipus the King’ and ‘Antigone’. Tiresias here is the blind and wise seer who advices Oedipus in governing the country. Which ever version it is, in my opinion Tiresias is a wise seer who has predicted the truth and only the truth. I also admire the way he conveys his message to Oedipus or Creon. He never forces them into doing things. He has his own way in convincing the king’s which would not offend them. I really respect Tiresias’s. Sophocles did a good job in moving about this character. In ‘Antigone’, Tiresias came in the nick of time to warn Creon of his actions. Unfortunately Creon refuse to believe the old man till the situation turns bloody. So who is Tiresias? He is the wise seer who almost save the kingdom.
HOW HARD IS IT TO ANALYSE A SHAKEPEREAN PLAY?
Although Shakespearean play always have a rather interesting plot, it is definitely hard to analyse.
First and foremost, the language itself is rather hard to understand. Shakespeare is famous for using implicit language in all his work. Other than that, due to the time frame in the play, the language used is based on that time frame. As an example: In King Lear, Shakespeare used 17th century language which is totally different from our language in the 21st century. Mostly he uses Royal language which needs extra attention to be understood.
On the other hand, the various scenes that occur in Shakespeare’s play can sometimes be confusing. As an example: In King Lear, the play started with Earl of Gloucester and Edmund came into the room to meet Kent, then Lear entered with his daughters, then the Fool and it goes on. With too many scenes happening in the play it is hard to identify the theme in the story. This play also confuses me as it involves too many characters until it takes some time to determine the main character. Furthermore, Shakespearean play tends to be very long and it might bore us.
Basically the language, setting of time and place, the various scenes and the length of a play all plays a major role in analyzing a play especially Shakespearean play. However, with hard work and determination a play can be analysed.
WHAT DO YOU THINK ABOUT THEATRE BEFORE?
Theatre in general is always associated with acting and stage performance. That is exactly what I have thought about theatre. As for me theatre is a part of the show business except it is done on stage not in front of a camera.
I also thought that theatre is boring and only suitable for adults and people who are really into literature. It is quite hard to understand. Why do I say so? Well during my first semester back in July 2004, I saw ‘30 Days in September’. Seeing the play without any prior knowledge about the play and what a play means really gave me a blur. The first thing that I do not understand about is why I am asked to dress formally. I did not know that a play has its own standard and we need to show a little respect. In the first half of the play, it was a total blur. I was confused why the same setting is used for various scenes. Only during the second half of the play the picture of what was happening and finally understood the play.
So, after starting this EDU 3217 class that I have begun to understand about theatre and that theatre is not merely acting but it is about performing and it involves various conventions.